Why Choose a Wood-Burning Grill? A Quick 2026 Buying Guide

Grilling on an Old Country BBQ Pit Santa Maria

  • Wood-burning grills give food a rich, smoky flavor that gas or electric grills just can’t match. The natural smoke adds depth to meat, vegetables, and even pizza or bread.
  • With a wood fire, you can grill, sear, smoke, roast, and even bake on some grills. It’s a good choice if you like trying different ways of cooking.
  • For many people, cooking over wood feels more hands-on and lively. Controlling the fire, adjusting the airflow, and hearing the crackle are all part of the experience, not just pressing a button.

What to Look for When Buying a Wood-Burning Grill

When you compare grills, think about these key factors. The best grill for you depends on how you like to cook.

Key Features & Build Quality

  • Grills made from heavy-duty steel or cast iron last longer when used with wood or charcoal. Flimsy grills can warp or rust quickly.
  • Good vents help you control how much oxygen reaches the fire, which changes how hot it burns and how much smoke you get. This is important for both searing and slow cooking.
  • Think about how much food you usually cook at once. A bigger cooking area or an adjustable grill height lets you cook several things at once, handle large cuts, or use different heat zones.
  • Some wood-burning grills, such as Santa Maria-style, let you raise or lower the cooking surface. This helps you control how much heat your food gets.
  • A grill that makes it easy to remove ash and spreads heat evenly is simpler to use and works better.
  • If your grill will stay outside all year, pick one with a weatherproof coating or rust-resistant materials. Using a cover or choosing a durable grill helps it last longer.

Steak and seafood grilling on a Hancock Santa Maria

🍖 Practical Considerations

  • If you usually grill quickly or cook steaks, look for a grill with adjustable height and strong direct heat. For long smoking or cooking for groups, a bigger surface and good airflow are more important.
  • Wood-burning grills need more attention, like managing fuel, tending the fire, and controlling airflow. If you want something easy, wood grills take more work than gas or pellet grills.
  • Think about your space. If you’re building a permanent outdoor kitchen, a built-in or heavy grill works well. For patios or small yards, a lighter, portable grill is better.
  • A well-made wood-burning grill might cost more, but it will last longer and give you better flavor in the long run.

🎯 Comparing Example Grill Styles

Here’s how different types of wood-burning grills compare, depending on your needs:

Santa Maria–style (e.g. Lodge Santa Maria Grill)

High-heat searing; steaks, burgers, quick grilling

Adjustable grate height for precise control; pure wood-fire flavor; dramatic open-fire cooking experience

High fuel use; harder to maintain stable low/indirect heat; less suited to long, slow cooks

Full wood-burning grill with large griddle/plate (e.g. Hancock Grill)

Versatile cooking — sear, smoke, grill, or griddle; larger meals or mixed cooking

Flexible cooking surface; handle larger portions; good for mixed menus

Larger footprint; more expensive; may require skill to manage temperature zones

Wood-fire pit / heavy-duty grill (e.g. Mojave-style / dedicated wood burning setups)

Slow smoking, long cooks, large gatherings

Great heat retention; smoke flavor; often multi-zone or multi-functional — grill, roast, smoke

Bulkier; higher cost; needs space and more maintenance; slower startup


Videl Santa Maria Grill Brasa II

📋 My Recommendations: Who Should Buy What

  • If you like classic, open-fire cooking for steaks, chops, or burgers, choose a Santa Maria-style grill. It gives you adjustable heat and a rustic fire-pit feel.
  • If you want to grill, smoke, griddle, or cook in different ways for family or groups, a larger wood-burning grill or a griddle-grill hybrid like a Hancock-style grill gives you lots of options.
  • If you want to cook slowly, or make big meals for groups, a heavy wood-burning or fire-pit grill, like a Mojave-style setup, gives you good heat retention, plenty of space, and flexibility.

Final Buying Checklist

Before you buy, make sure your wood-burning grill meets these requirements:

  • Solid, durable construction (steel or heavy materials)
  • Adequate cooking surface for your typical meals
  • Adjustable grill height / cooking-surface control OR good airflow design
  • Easy ash removal or manageable cleanup
  • Suitable for your outdoor space (footprint, ventilation, clearance from combustibles)
  • If needed: features like side shelves, weatherproof cover, and grate material that withstands high heat and wear.

Browse Fire Goddess's selection of wood-burning grills.


Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.